🔴 Section 185(1): Prohibited Loans
A company cannot directly or indirectly:
- Advance loans (including book debts), or
- Give guarantees or security in connection with any loan taken by:
- Any director of the company or its holding company
- Any partner or relative of such director
- Any firm in which such director or relative is a partner
This section prohibits such transactions to protect stakeholders and prevent misuse of company funds.
✅ Permitted Exceptions Under Section 185
A company may lend to directors/related persons if ALL the following apply:
✅ Applicable to Private Companies only:
- No body corporate has invested in the company’s share capital.
- Company’s borrowings from banks/FIs/other companies < twice its paid-up share capital or ₹50 crore, whichever is lower.
- The company has not defaulted in repayment of any borrowings at the time of transaction.
📊 Loan Limits (When Conditions Are Met)
Loans may be granted to directors, their relatives, or specified persons up to the higher of:
Basis | Maximum Loan Limit |
---|---|
60% of Paid-up Share Capital + Free Reserves + Securities Premium | ✅ Permitted |
100% of Free Reserves + Securities Premium | ✅ Permitted |
📌 Special Cases Permitted under Section 185(2)
A company can give loans to its directors under the following scenarios:
- ✅ As a condition of service extended to all employees.
- ✅ In the ordinary course of business, where interest is charged not less than the rate prescribed under RBI regulations.
- ✅ To a wholly-owned subsidiary company (loan or guarantee/security).
- ✅ To a joint venture company (guarantee/security).
🌍 Loan to NRI Directors
While the Companies Act, 2013 does not distinguish between resident and non-resident directors for the purpose of Section 185, NRI Directors are still subject to the same restrictions. Therefore:
- ✅ Loans to NRI Directors are prohibited under Section 185(1), unless the exceptions under Section 185(2) or the Private Company exemptions (above) apply.
- ✅ Additionally, FEMA compliance is required when remitting funds to or from NRI accounts (e.g., NRO/NRE).
🏦 Loans to Other Persons (Non-Directors)
- ✅ Permitted without limit, unless the transaction is not on an arm’s length basis or not in the ordinary course of business.
- 🚫 If the person is a shareholder holding ≥10% in a closely held company (i.e., not widely held), the loan may be treated as a Deemed Dividend (u/s 2(22)(e) of the Income Tax Act) and is taxable in the hands of the shareholder.
💼 Deposits Not Considered
Money accepted from directors or their relatives is not treated as “deposits” under the Companies Act, 2013, provided appropriate declaration is furnished.
📘 Quick Compliance Checklist
Situation | Permitted? | Conditions |
---|---|---|
Loan to director (general) | ❌ Not permitted | Unless exception applies |
Loan to NRI director | ❌ Not permitted | Same as above; plus FEMA compliance |
Loan to director as employee | ✅ Permitted | As part of service conditions |
Loan to WOS or JV | ✅ Permitted | Subject to section 185(2) |
Loan to other persons (non-directors) | ✅ Permitted | On arm’s length, ordinary course |
Loan to 10%+ shareholder (closely held) | ✅ But taxable | As deemed dividend under IT Act |